France Big Challenge:
The Muslim Headscarf Ban

France’s bold new
effort to rein in Muslim fundamentalism was put to the test
today, with a new law that bans Islamic headscarves taking force
as students went back to school. But the stakes have been raised
by a hostage crisis countries away as Islamic radicals in Iraq
continue to hold two French journalists hostage, demanding that
the law be scrapped or the two will be killed. Mohammed Bechari,
a vice president of the French Council for the Muslim Faith,
said the return to class would be difficult and urged calm. “The
hostage-takers are just waiting for a provocation,” Bechari told
Le Figaro newspaper before departing for Iraq with a delegation
of French Muslim leaders to help in the hostage crisis. “We must
be responsible.” The law has been among the most divisive issues
in recent times in France, and it is not yet clear whether
Muslim girls who cover their heads will defy it or compromise
their beliefs to stay in school. The law forbids conspicuous
religious signs or apparel in public schools, including Jewish
skull caps and large Christian crosses. However, it is aimed at
Islamic headscarves and meant to counter a rise in Muslim
fundamentalism reportedly taking root in schools. As classes
opened, one Muslim girl in the working-class Paris suburb of
Aubervilliers said she was leaving her headscarf at home. “I was
always treated badly and I felt uncomfortable, so I decided to
take it off,” said Nadia Aradi, 16, before heading through the
school gates. Several Muslim organisations have set up hot lines
to advise or council young girls in a quandary over the law.
Sofia Rahem said her association, GFaim2Savoir, “I’m Hungry for
Knowledge,” had received “an enormous number” of calls. “They
are young girls in distress who don’t know what to do with their
future,” said Rahem, a 23-year-old university student who wears
a headscarf. “They fear the return to school knowing they won’t
be accept with a scarf.” The law, passed in March, has raised
arguments over religious freedom, free expression and France’s
much cherished principle, secularism, seen by authorities as
under threat by increasingly militant Muslims. France’s Muslim
population is an estimated five million, the largest in Western
Europe. Today, there were no immediate reports of dramatic
scenes of rejection at school gates. The law specifies that no
one will be immediately excluded from school. It calls for a
period of dialogue, though Francois Fillon, the education
minister, has stressed that there is no room for negotiations.
“There is no question today of excluding. It is a question of
convincing,” he said. Experts predict a rash of court cases
brought by Muslims who test the law by wearing “discreet” head
coverings like bandannas. The law allows for discreet religious
signs.
|
US seeks quick UN vote to press Syria
on Lebanon
UNITED
NATIONS - The United States called for a Thursday vote on a
resolution telling Syria to stop interfering in Lebanon’s
presidential election despite strong opposition to the measure in
the U.N. Security Council.
During a
closed-door meeting late on Wednesday, just six of the council’s
15 members—France, Britain, Germany, Spain and Romania as well as
the United States—backed the US-drafted resolution while most of
the others either raised questions or expressed opposition,
diplomats said. Nine “yes” votes are required for council
approval. The resolution aims to head off a move in Lebanon’s
parliament to amend the constitution and extend the term of its
Syrian-backed president, Emile Lahoud, for three more years. The
128-member assembly has set a vote on the constitutional change
for Friday and officials said the amendment would easily win
the required two-thirds majority. “We intend to seek a vote
tomorrow because the situation is that in Lebanon they have a very
fast process for amending the constitution,” that in Lebanon they
have a very fast process for amending the constitution,” US
Ambassador John Danforth told reporters. “The government of Syria
has put the hammer on Lebanon, basically instructing Lebanon to
bend the constitution—not to change the election process, but to
abort the election process,” he said. The resolution would call
for the “strict respect of Lebanon’s sovereignty” and demand the
rapid withdrawal of Syrian forces from Lebanon and a disbanding of
all militias. It would declare the council’s support for “a free
and fair electoral process in Lebanon’s upcoming presidential
election conducted according to Lebanese constitutional rules
devised without foreign interference or influence.” During the
closed-door council meeting, Algeria, Pakistan and the Philippines
expressed strong opposition to the draft resolution, saying
Washington was seeking to interfere in Lebanon’s internal affairs.
They also accused the United States of exercising a double
standard in seeking to force a Syrian withdrawal from Lebanese
soil while allowing Israel to continue to occupy Palestinian lands
captured in a 1967 war. Council members China, Brazil and Chile
also raised questions about the measure’s impact on Lebanese
sovereignty, diplomats said. “It is up to the Lebanese people and
their representatives to decide on matters related to their own
situation,” Syrian Ambassador Fayssal Mekdad told reporters after
the meeting. ”Syria believes there was no justification whatsoever
for the Security Council to discuss such an issue.” Mekdad
said he regretted that France had agreed to co-sponsor the
resolution, saying Paris had failed to respect the spirit of its
friendship with Damascus and with other Arab governments “on
Muslim issues.” Danforth acknowledged the measure would not be
binding on the Beirut government, but said it was important for
the council to “do the best we can.” “Let’s at least condemn
something as being just plain wrong,” he said.
   
|